Office of the President: Brother Michael McGinniss, F.S.C.
  Mr. James Gallagher (Interim President, 2014-present)
  Brother Michael McGinniss (1999 to 2014)
  Mr. Nicholas Giordano (Interim President, 1998-1999)
  Brother Joseph Burke (1992-1998)
  Brother Patrick Ellis (1977-1992)
  Brother Daniel Burke (1969-1976)
  Brother Daniel Bernian
(1958-1969)
  Brother Erminus Stanislaus (1952-1958)
  Brother Gregorian Paul (1945-1952)
  Brother Dominic Luke (1945)
  Brother Emilian James (1941-1945)
  Brother Edwin Anselm (1932-1941)
  Brother Elzear Alfred (1928-1932)
  Brother Dorotheus Lewis (1925-1928)
  Brother Galbert Lucian (1922-1925)
  Brother Ennodius Richard (1917-1922)
  Brother Denis Edward (1911-1917)
  Brother Abdas John (1903-1911)
  Brother Wolfred of Mary (1900-1903)
  Brother Isidore John (1890-1900)
  Brother Abraham of Jesus (1889-1890)
  Brother Isidore John (1887-1889)
  Brother Fabrician (1885-1887)
  Brother Clementian (1883-1885)
  Brother Romuald (1878-1883)
  Brother Stephen of Jesus (1876-1878)
  Brother Joachim of Mary (1875-1876)
  Brother Noah (1872-1875)
  Brother Oliver (1863-1872)
  Brother Teliow (1863)